Deliberative Democracy Under the Influence of Populist Current

Authors

  • Gabriela NEMŢOI Associate. Prof. PhD, ‟‟Ștefan cel Mare” University of Suceava

Keywords:

European populism, democracy, representatives, deliberative democracy, constitutional democracy.

Abstract

The phrase “deliberative democracy” is attributed to the author Joseph Bessett, who in the article Democracy the majority principle in republican government, published in 1980, argued about a new form of democracy in contradiction with classical democracy, about deliberative democracy as an authentic alternative to traditional forms. In this respect, it is admitted that the political decisions cannot be legitimized without an early negotiation dialogue [1: 1]. The rise of populism in Central and Eastern Europe is a justification for the democratic crisis, a failure of representative politics after 1989. A negative effect of the populist current was also seen in Romania, Hungary or Poland. In this sense, applying a reorientation to a policy based on a deliberate democratic culture with populist influences was considered to be a solution that would justify the interference between populism and a deliberative democracy. The participation in the vote of the citizens of Eastern Europe who initially see in the left parties the popular interest is radically changing in the present, towards the right parties that no longer identify with pure right principles. Furthermore, moving populism from the left foot to the right foot does not require sacrifice. In the end, it all comes down to changing symbols, changing vocabulary but within the same type of policy based on a common way of thinking both left and right. The distinction between the two is greatly minimized. The transitional period in which the executives put pressure on the law institutions and themselves with a rather weak identity, on the press, on the media, allowed a reassessment of the transient moments, the populist discourse having the capacity to capture democracy of a populist state [2:132]. The diagnosis of the causes of the increase of populism was based on two major pillars, one being the failure of the national institutions located in the space of national constitutions and the second is the influence of the international institutions of the EU and of the Council of Europe that do not wish to sanction the fall towards populism [3:219].

References

Dryzek J. Deliberative Democracy and Beyond: Liberals, Critics, Contestation. New York: Oxford Unersity Press; 2000

Rupnik J. „The liberal return of Hungary: how things went wrong ”. Journal of Democracy; 2012; 23 (3).

Bugaric B. „A crisis of constitutional democracy in post-communist Europe: The strands between "democracy and authoritarianism", Vol. 13 International Journal of Constitutional Law; 2015, 13.

Mueller, JW. What is populism? Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press; 2016

Suteu S. ”The populist return to Central and Eastern Europe: is deliberative democracy part of the solution?” Journals European Constitutional Law Review; 2019: 15 (3): 488-518. Available at: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/european-constitutional-lawreview/article/populist-turn-in-central-and-eastern-europe-is-deliberativedemocracy-part-of-th solution/05A8387AD3D9601BF8FFAD7D9363C983

Sandu A, Ignatescu C. Retributivity and Public Perception on the NonCustodial Sanctions. Revista Romaneasca pentru Educatie Multidimensionala; 2017, 9(3), 103-128.

Groenlund, K, Bachtiger A,Setala M (eds.). Deliberative Mini-Publics: Implicing Citizens in the Democratic Process, ECPR Press; 2014

Reuchamps M, Suiter J (eds). Constitutional Deliberative Democracy in Europe, ECPR Press; 2016

Parvu CA, “Syndrome or Symptom: Populist and Democratic Malise in Post-Communist Romania”, In: Kopecek, M. and Wcisik, P. (eds.), Transition thinking: Liberal democracy, authoritarian pasts and intellectual history in Central Europe East after 1989, EU Press; 2015: 259

Taggart P. ”Populism and the Pathology of Representative Politics”. In: Meny Y Surel Y (eds.), Democracies and the Populist Challenge (Palgrave 2002),

Mungiu-Pippidi A. „EU Accession Is No “End of History”‟ Journal of Democracy, Vol. 18; 2007

Walker N. ”Populism and Constitutional Tension”, International Journal of Constitutional Law, Volume 17; 2019.

Della Porta Donatella, Soceal Movements, Ed. Willey Blackewell, 2005.

Arato A. „Constitutions and Continuity in the East European Transitions Part I: Continuity and Its Crisis‟, Volume no.1 Constellations; 1994

Pârvu C. Populism, Retoric and Political Representation. București: Editura Universității; 2016

. Kamrowska-Zaluska, D. “Participatory budget in Poland - lack of connection in the process of urban regeneration”, 161 Procedia Engineering 161: (2016) 1996-2000; December 2016

Sintomer Y, Herzberg C, Rocke A. „Participatory Budgeting in Europe: Potentials and Challenges‟, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, Volume. No. 32; 2008

Blokker P. „The Romanian Constitution and Civic Engagement‟, Journal of International Constitutional Law; Vienna, Volume no. 11; 2017.

Mueller JW. „Eastern Europe Goes South: Disappearing Democracy in the EU's Newest Members‟, 93 Foreign Affairs; Mar/Apr 2014

Downloads

Published

2019-12-11

How to Cite

NEMŢOI, G. (2019). Deliberative Democracy Under the Influence of Populist Current. European Journal of Law and Public Administration, 6(2), 236-244. Retrieved from https://lumenpublishing.com/journals/index.php/ejlpa/article/view/2346

Most read articles by the same author(s)

1 2 > >>